User talk:Reidgreg: Difference between revisions

(Nomination of The Same Boat for deletion at AfD)
 
To customise your preferences for automated AfD notifications for articles to which you've significantly contributed (or to opt-out entirely), please visit [[User:SDZeroBot/AfD notifier|the configuration page]]. Delivered by ''[[User:SDZeroBot|SDZeroBot]]'' ([[User talk:SDZeroBot|talk]]) 01:08, 1 December 2020 (UTC)<!-- User:SDZeroBot/AfD notifier/template -->
 
:The deletion discussion was closed after two days (before I saw this) as '''keep'''. Almost 90 {{abbr|TWD|The Walking Dead}} episode articles had been put forward. The response (which was probably largely from the authors of those articles) was that while many of the articles were underdeveloped or plot-heavy, that they met general notability guidelines due to reviews in reliable sources. Some dismissed the deletion request on procedural grounds as it would be time consuming to consider each of the nominated articles.
:The article which I was pinged for (linked above) is the feminist episode featuring Carol, Maggie, and female antagonists. I was a relatively new editor when I worked on it (which probably shows) though Tools says I have 50% authorship after more than four years, so most of it stuck. The critical feedback I received on the article talk page from {{noping|Drovethrughosts}} pushed me to become a more responsible editor, including my stint with the Guild of Copy Editors to work on paraphrasing, quoting and encyclopedic tone. I ought to go back to these articles to tidy up a bit, now that I sortof know what I'm doing. – [[User:Reidgreg|Reidgreg]] ([[User talk:Reidgreg#top|talk]]) 14:20, 3 December 2020 (UTC)