| Year
|
Winner and nominees
|
Film
|
Role
|
|---|
| 1990 |
Danny Glover |
To Sleep with Anger |
Harry
|
| Martin Priest |
The Plot Against Harry |
Harry Plotnick
|
| Christopher Reid |
House Party |
Kid
|
| Michael Rooker |
Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer |
Henry
|
| Christian Slater |
Pump Up the Volume |
Mark Hunter
|
| 1991 |
River Phoenix |
My Own Private Idaho |
Mike "Mikey" Waters
|
| Doug E. Doug |
Hangin' with the Homeboys |
Willie
|
| Robert Duvall |
Rambling Rose |
Daddy Hillyer
|
| Gary Oldman |
Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead |
Rosencrantz
|
| William Russ |
Pastime |
Roy Dean Bream
|
| 1992 |
Harvey Keitel |
Bad Lieutenant |
The Lieutenant
|
| Craig Chester |
Swoon |
Nathan Leopold, Jr.
|
| Laurence Fishburne |
Deep Cover |
Russell Stevens / John Hull
|
| Peter Greene |
Laws of Gravity |
Jimmy
|
| Michael Rapaport |
Zebrahead |
Zack
|
| 1993 |
Jeff Bridges |
American Heart |
Jack Kelson
|
| Vincent D'Onofrio |
Household Saints |
Joseph Santangelo
|
| Mitchell Lichtenstein |
The Wedding Banquet |
Simon
|
| Matthew Modine |
Equinox |
Henry Petosa / Freddy Ace
|
| Tyrin Turner |
Menace II Society |
Caine
|
| 1994 |
Samuel L. Jackson |
Pulp Fiction |
Jules Winnfield
|
| Sihung Lung |
Eat Drink Man Woman |
Chu
|
| William H. Macy |
Oleanna |
John
|
| Campbell Scott |
Mrs. Parker and the Vicious Circle |
Robert Benchley
|
| Jon Seda |
I Like It Like That |
Chino Linares
|
| 1995 |
Sean Penn |
Dead Man Walking |
Matthew Poncelet
|
| Nicolas Cage |
Leaving Las Vegas |
Ben Sanderson
|
| Tim Roth |
Little Odessa |
Joshua Shapira
|
| Jimmy Smits |
My Family |
Jimmy Sánchez
|
| Kevin Spacey |
Swimming with Sharks |
Buddy Ackerman
|
| 1996 |
William H. Macy |
Fargo |
Jerry Lundegaard
|
| Chris Cooper |
Lone Star |
Sheriff Sam Deeds
|
| Chris Penn |
The Funeral |
Chez
|
| Tony Shalhoub |
Big Night |
Primo
|
| Stanley Tucci |
Secondo
|
| 1997 |
Robert Duvall |
The Apostle |
Euliss "Sonny" Dewey / The Apostle E.F.
|
| Peter Fonda |
Ulee's Gold |
Ulysses "Ulee" Jackson
|
| Christopher Guest |
Waiting for Guffman |
Corky St. Clair
|
| Philip Baker Hall |
Hard Eight |
Sydney Brown
|
| John Turturro |
Box of Moon Light |
Al Fountain
|
| 1998 |
Ian McKellen |
Gods and Monsters |
James Whale
|
| Dylan Baker |
Happiness |
Bill Maplewood
|
| Nick Nolte |
Affliction |
Wade Whitehouse
|
| Sean Penn |
Hurlyburly |
Eddie
|
| Courtney B. Vance |
Blind Faith |
John Williams
|
| 1999 |
Richard Farnsworth |
The Straight Story |
Alvin Straight
|
| John Cusack |
Being John Malkovich |
Craig Schwartz
|
| Terence Stamp |
The Limey |
Wilson
|
| David Strathairn |
Limbo |
Joe "Jumpin" Gastineau
|
| Noble Willingham |
The Corndog Man |
Ace Barker
|
.jpg)