Bonner Fellers

Bonner Frank Fellers (February 7, 1896 – October 7, 1973) was a US Army officer who served during World War II as military attaché and director of psychological warfare. He is notable as the military attaché in Egypt whose extensive transmissions of detailed British tactical information were intercepted by Axis agents and passed to German Field Marshal Erwin Rommel for over six months, which contributed to disastrous British defeats at Gazala and Tobruk in June 1942. He was considered a protégé of General Douglas MacArthur.

Bonner Fellers
ANCExplorer Bonner Fellers grave.jpg
Grave at Arlington National Cemetery
Birth nameBonner Frank Fellers
Born(1896-02-07)February 7, 1896
Ridge Farm, Illinois
DiedOctober 7, 1973(1973-10-07) (aged 77)
AllegianceUnited States United States of America
Service/branchUnited States Army seal United States Army
Years of service1918–1946
RankUS-O7 insignia.svg Brigadier General
Battles/warsWorld War I
World War II
AwardsDistinguished Service Medal (2)
Legion of Merit

Early military careerEdit

Fellers entered the United States Military Academy at West Point in June 1916. The increased need for junior officers during the First World War caused Fellers's class to be accelerated and to graduate on November 1, 1918. Upon his graduation, Fellers was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Coast Artillery Corps.

Fellers was promoted to first lieutenant in October 1919 and graduated from the Coast Artillery School Basic Course in 1920. The drastic reduction in the Army after the war created limited opportunities for promotion and so Fellers was not promoted to captain until December 3, 1934. In 1935, he graduated from the Command and General Staff School and the Chemical Warfare Service Field Officers Course, when he completed his soon-to-be-influential thesis "The Psychology of the Japanese Soldier."[1]

Fellers served three tours of duty in the Philippines in the 1920s and the 1930s. His assignments included helping to open the Philippine Military Academy, the Philippines' "West Point," and liaisoning with Philippine President Manuel Quezon. The Philippines awarded him its Distinguished Service Star for his contributions to its defenses.[2]

Fellers graduated from the US Army War College in 1939 and was promoted to major on July 1, 1940. He was promoted to temporary lieutenant colonel on September 15, 1941 and to temporary colonel the next month.[3]

World War IIEdit

Italians and Germans access to Fellers's reportsEdit

In October 1940,[4] Major Fellers was assigned as military attaché to the US embassy in Egypt. He was assigned the duty of monitoring and reporting on British military operations in the Mediterranean and Middle East Theatre. The British granted Fellers access to their activities and information. He dutifully reported everything he learned to his superiors in the United States. His reports were read by President Franklin Roosevelt, the head of American intelligence, and the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Fellers was concerned about the security of the "Black Code" of the US State Department. His concerns were overridden and he sent his reports by radio. The US government did not know the details of the code had been stolen from the US embassy in Italy in September 1941 shortly before the US entered the war in a night raid into the embassy by Italian spies from the Servizio Informazioni Militare (SIM), the Italian military intelligence service. That enabled the Italians to read the reports, and within eight hours, the most secret data on British "strengths, positions, losses, reinforcements, supply, situation, plans, morale etc" were in the hands of the German and the Italian militaries.[5] Around the same time, it was also broken by German cryptanalysts.[6]

Beginning in mid-December 1941, coincidentally when the US entered the war, Germany could identify Fellers's reports until June 29, 1942, when Fellers switched to a newly adopted US code system.[7]

Fellers's radiograms provided to the Axis detailed, extensive, and timely information about troop movements and equipment. Information from his messages alerted the Axis to British convoy operations in the Battle of the Mediterranean, including efforts to resupply the garrison of Malta. In January 1942 information about numbers and the condition of British forces was provided to General Rommel, the famed German commander in Africa, who could thus plan his operations with reliable knowledge of what the opposing forces were. The Germans referred to Fellers as die gute Quelle ("the good source"). Rommel referred to him as "the little fellow."[8]

The information leak cost the Allies many lives. For example, in June 1942, the British attempted to resupply Malta, which was under constant air attack and was being starved. The British determined to sail two supply convoys simultaneously in the hopes that if one were to become discovered, attacks upon it would distract the Axis from the other. Codenamed Operation Vigorous and Harpoon and sailing from Alexandria in the east and Gibraltar in the west, respectively, their sailing was timed with an effort by special forces teams to neutralize Axis ships and aircraft. Fellers efficiently reported all of that in his cable, No. 11119 dated June 11, which was intercepted in both Rome and by the German Military High Command Cipher Branch (OKW Chiffrierabteilung). It read, in part:[8]

NIGHTS OF JUNE 12TH JUNE 13TH BRITISH SABOTAGE UNITS PLAN SIMULTANEOUS STICKER BOMB ATTACKS AGAINST AIRCRAFT ON 9 AXIS AIRDROMES. PLANS TO REACH OBJECTIVES BY PARACHUTES AND LONG RANGE DESERT PATROL.

British and Free French raiders went into action behind the lines in Libya and on the island of Crete. In most of the attacks, the raiders were met with accurate fire of the alerted garrisons and suffered heavy losses but failed to inflict any damage upon the Luftwaffe. Their only success came when Fellers's unwitting early warning was not received or were ignored or ineptly handled. Meanwhile, both convoys were located and came under attack. A day after leaving Gibraltar, Convoy Harpoon's six merchant ships and their escorts came under continuous air and surface attack. Only two of the merchant ships survived to reach Malta. Convoy Vigorous was the larger effort. Made up of 11 merchant ships, it suffered such serious losses that it was forced to turn back to Egypt.[8]

Debates continue on the Fellers leaks' overall impact on the battle for North Africa. For example, John Ferris argues that because Fellers sometimes reported imperfect information and assessments, the leaks also contributed to Rommel's ultimate defeat: "In its last days of life, after Tobruk fell, the 'Good Source' bolstered Rommel's decision to drive all-out on Alexandria, his native over-optimism reinforced by Bonner Fellers' belief that the British would crack under one last blow. Both men were wrong; this time the intelligence failure led to German defeat."[9]

Fellers had been ordered to use the State Department code over his objections. For example, on February 2, 1942, Fellers reported "Believe that code compromised" but was instructed thereafter that the code was secure.[10]

British suspect leak from EgyptEdit

Ultra intercepts seen only by the British indicated the Germans were gaining information from a source in Egypt, and British intelligence had considered Fellers as a possible source. On June 10, 1942, the British became convinced Fellers's reports were compromised because an intercept had compared British tactics negatively to American tactics. The British informed the Americans on June 12, who, on June 14, confirmed the finding that Fellers's reports were the source. Fellers switched codes on June 29, which ended the leaks.[11]

Fellers was not found at fault for the interception of his reports, but he was transferred from Egypt on 7 July 1942. His successor as attaché used the US military cipher, which the Germans could not read. Upon returning to the United States, Fellers was decorated with the Distinguished Service Medal for his analysis and reporting of the North African situation. He was also promoted to brigadier general, the first in the West Point Class of 1918, on December 4, 1942.

While assigned to the Office of Strategic Services (OSS) in Washington, he was, as recalled by a colleague, "the most violent anglophobe I have encountered."[12] However, that comment may be colored by the context of the American-British intelligence situation of the time. Fellers's North African reports, which his Distinguished Service Medal citation characterized as "models of clarity and accuracy," were bluntly critical of British weapons, operations, and leadership: "The Eighth Army has failed to maintain the morale of its troops; its tactical conceptions were always wrong, it neglected completely cooperation between the various arms; its reactions to the lightning changes in the battlefield were always slow."[13] Such assessments, meant for American officials, were intercepted from the Germans by the British Ultra signals intelligence.

Despite his anti-British attitude, Fellers and his reports influenced decisions to bring American supplies and troops to aid the British in North Africa. Throughout his tenure in North Africa, Fellers advocated for increased American support for the British in North Africa, which included both weapons and a commitment of American troops. This was at odds with the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the U.S. European Command as to the level of weapons support and an American troop landing. The military policy then was that saving the British in North Africa was not strategically required, especially not through a North Africa invasion (Operation Torch), which would divert focus from Operation Bolero, a plan for an early European invasion.

President Roosevelt admired Fellers's reports and was influenced by them enough so that on June 29, General George Marshall wrote to Roosevelt, "Fellers is a very valuable observer but his responsibilities are not those of a strategist and his views are in opposition to mine and those of the entire Operations Division."[14] The President invited Fellers to the White House upon his return from Cairo, and they met on July 30, 1942. "Consistent with his previous reporting through 1942, Fellers argued for robust and expeditious reinforcement of British forces in the Middle East."[15] Thus, Fellers' blunt criticism and his analysis of the Middle East's strategic importance may well have influenced Roosevelt's decisions to reinforce the Eighth Army and to support Operation Torch.

Transfer to PacificEdit

In the summer of 1943, Fellers left his job in the OSS, where he played a role in planning psychological warfare, and he returned to the Southwest Pacific and resumed working for General MacArthur. Fellers later served as military secretary and the Chief of Psychological Operations under MacArthur.

During the liberation of the Philippines from the Japanese, Fellers had several assignments, including Director of Civil Affairs for the Philippines.[16] For his efforts, Fellers received a second Philippine Distinguished Service Star.[17]

There are stories that suggest that General Dwight Eisenhower had been at odds with Fellers since they served together under General MacArthur in the Philippines. In a recollection in her personal diary, the Countess of Ranfurly wrote of a comment made by Eisenhower when she expressed admiration for Fellers. Eisenhower reportedly replied, "Any friend of Bonner Fellers is no friend of mine!"[18] Eisenhower apologized the next day for his rudeness. Purportedly, Eisenhower's dislike of Fellers had begun at the time the two were serving under MacArthur. MacArthur had strained his relationship with Eisenhower in 1936–1937 in the Philippines. Eisenhower may have developed such a view because he was aware of the North Africa leaks that had strained British relations and because Fellers had been instrumental in getting presidential approval of increased support for the British in North Africa including Operation Torch, which was not supported by the U.S. military command, including Eisenhower.

Post-war JapanEdit

After the war, Fellers played a major role in the occupation of Japan. Among his duties was liaison between HQ and the Imperial Household. Soon after occupation began, Fellers wrote several influential memoranda concerning why it would be advantageous for the occupation, reconstruction of Japan, and long-term US interests to keep the Emperor in place if he was not clearly responsible for war crimes.[19]

Fellers met with the major defendants of the Tokyo tribunal. In their research and analysis of events and considerable controversy about the time period, according to the historians Herbert Bix and John W. Dower, Fellers, under an assignment with the codename "Operation Blacklist," allowed them to co-ordinate their stories to exonerate Emperor Hirohito and all members of his family.[20][21] That was at the direction of MacArthur, now head of SCAP, who had decided that there was to be no criminal prosecution of the Emperor and his family.

General Fellers, who came from a Religious Society of Friends family (commonly known as Quakers) and attended the Quaker-affiliated Earlham College,[2] was instrumental in the selection of Elizabeth Vining, an American Quaker educator, as tutor to the Emperor's children. She was followed after four years by another Quaker educator, Esther Rhoads.[22]

In 1971, Hirohito conferred on Fellers the Second Order of the Sacred Treasure "in recognition of your long-standing contribution to promoting friendship between Japan and the United States."[23]

Fellers's role in exonerating Hirohito is the main subject of the 2012 film Emperor.

Fellers was also familiar with the writings of Lafcadio Hearn and became a friend of Hearn's descendants in Japan, the Koizumi family.[24]

Retirement from the Army and politicsEdit

In October 1946, Fellers reverted to the rank of colonel as part of a reduction in rank of 212 generals.[25] He retired from the Army on November 30, 1946. In 1948, his retirement rank was reinstated as brigadier general.

After retiring from the Army, he worked for the Republican National Committee in Washington, DC. In 1952 Fellers was actively involved in promoting Robert A. Taft as a presidential candidate. Fellers was a member of the John Birch Society, which is named after a military intelligence officer, who was considered by its founding members to be the first casualty of the Cold War. In 1953 Fellers, wrote a book: Wings for Peace: A Primer for a New Defense (Chicago: Henry Regnery Co., 1953). Fellers was also involved in promoting Barry Goldwater for the presidency during the 1964 campaign.

Military awardsEdit

     
   
Distinguished Service Medal
with oak leaf cluster
Legion of Merit World War I Victory Medal Army of Occupation of Germany Medal
American Defense Service Medal
with star
European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign Medal
with two stars
Asiatic-Pacific Campaign Medal
with six stars
World War II Victory Medal Army of Occupation Medal
with "Japan" clasp
Philippine Liberation Medal
with two stars

PromotionsEdit

Insignia Rank Component Date
No insignia Cadet United States Military Academy June 15, 1916
  Second lieutenant Coast Artillery Corps, Regular Army November 1, 1918
  First lieutenant Regular Army October 1, 1919
  Captain Regular Army December 3, 1934
  Major Regular Army July 1, 1940
  Lieutenant colonel Army of the United States September 15, 1941
  Colonel Army of the United States October 15, 1941
  Brigadier general Army of the United States December 4, 1942
  Lieutenant colonel Regular Army December 11, 1942
  Colonel Army of the United States January 31, 1946
  Colonel Retired List November 30, 1946
  Brigadier General Retired List June 30, 1948
[26]

See alsoEdit

ReferencesEdit

Notes

  1. ^ Army Register, 1936. p. 223.
  2. ^ a b Congressional Record, November 5, 1973, Vol. 119, No. 168, available at http://bonnerfellers.com/uploads/B.Fellers_Cong_Record_Nov_5_1973.pdf
  3. ^ Army Register, 1945. p. 302
  4. ^ "ATTACHE TO GO TO CAIRO; U.S. Fills Military Post Second Time in History" (https://www.nytimes.com/1940/10/12/archives/attache-to-go-to-cairo-us-fills-military-post-second-time-in.html) The New York Times. 8 October 1940, Retrieved 13 August 2013. Subscription required.
  5. ^ Jenner, C. J. (2008), Turning the Hinge of Fate: Good Source and the UK-U.S. Intelligence Alliance, 1940–1942. Diplomatic History, 32: 165–205, available with subscription or fee at http://dh.oxfordjournals.org/content/32/2/165.extract. Matloff, M. and Snell, E.M., Strategic Planning for Coalition Warfare, 1941-1942 (Washington, DC, 1990), 253, available at http://www.history.army.mil/html/books/001/1-3/CMH_Pub_1-3.pdf.
  6. ^ Deac, Wil. "Intercepted Communications for Field Marshal Erwin Rommel". The History Net. Archived from the original on 2008-03-30. Retrieved 2008-02-03.
  7. ^ Jenner, pp. 170 & 199
  8. ^ a b c Wil Deac (June 12, 2006). "Intercepted Communications for Field Marshal Erwin Rommel". World War II Magazine.
  9. ^ Ferris, J. (2008), available at http://www.h-net.org/~diplo/reviews/PDF/Ferris-Jenner.pdf.
  10. ^ Jenner, p. 171, citing Fellers to Military Intelligence Division, 1 February 1942, U.S. Military Attaché, Cairo, Records of the War Department General and Special Staffs, RG 165, NARA
  11. ^ Jenner, pp. 197-198
  12. ^ Deutsch, Harold C.; et al. (2010). If the Allies Had Fallen. New York: Skyhorse Publishing. p. 336. ISBN 978-1616085469.
  13. ^ Quoted by Jenner, p. 176, cited to "The Contribution of the Information Service to the May–June 1942 Offensive in North Africa," File 1035, RG 457, NARA.
  14. ^ Jenner, p. 185, citing Memorandum, Chief of Staff for President, 23 June 1942, RG 218, NARA
  15. ^ Jenner, p. 200
  16. ^ See, for example, this discussion of the implementation of Fellers' civil administration master plan in "Leyte Town Quick in Reviving Itself" (http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F60617FB3555157B93C1A8178AD95F408485F9) The New York Times 13 November 1944 Retrieved 06 October 2013. Subscription required.
  17. ^ Congressional Record, November 5, 1973, Volume 119, No. 168, available at http://bonnerfellers.com/uploads/B.Fellers_Cong_Record_Nov_5_1973.pdf
  18. ^ Ranfurly, Hermione. To War With Whitaker: The Wartime Diaries of the Countess of Ranfurly 1939-45. Mandarin,1994
  19. ^ One memo is available at http://bonnerfellers.com/uploads/B.Fellers_Memo_to_MacArthur_Oct_2_1945.pdf
  20. ^ Bix, Herbert P. Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan, Perennial, 2001, p. 583
  21. ^ Dower, John W. Embracing Defeat, 1999
  22. ^ "Finding Aid for the ESTHER B. RHOADS PAPERS" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on October 21, 2013.
  23. ^ Cited in the Congressional Record, November 5, 1973, Volume 119, No. 168.
  24. ^ [1]
  25. ^ "212 GENERALS CUT TO COLONEL RANK". The New York Times. 8 March 1946. Retrieved 5 March 2013. Subscription required.
  26. ^ Register of Commissioned Officers of the United States Army, 1948, vol. 2, pg. 2186.

Bibliography

External linksEdit